Segundo o IMDB a lenda de Ichabod Crane recebeu um total de 24 prêmios e 28 indicações. Confira:

Oscar

• Best Art Direction-Set Decoration

Indicado Best Cinematography, Best Costume Design

BAFTA Awards

• Best Production Design
• Best Costume Design

Nomeado Best Achievement in Special Visual Effects

Saturn Award

• Best Actress - Christina Ricci
• Best Music

Nomeado Best Actor - Johnny Depp, Best Supporting Actor - Christopher Walken, Best Supporting Actress - Miranda Richardson, Best Director, Best Writer, Best Costumes, Best Make-Up, Best Special Effects

American Society of Cinematographers
Nomeado Outstanding Achievement in Cinematography in Theatrical Releases

Art Directors Guild

• Excellence in Production Design Award

BMI Film &TV Awards

• BMI Film Music Award

Blockbuster Entertainment Awards

• Favorite Actress - Horror - Christina Ricci
• Favorite Actor - Horror - Johnny Depp
• Favorite Supporting Actress - Horror - Miranda Richardson

Nomeado Favorite Supporting Actor - Horror - Marc Pickering

Boston Society of Film Critics Awards

• Best Cinematography

Chicago Film Critics Association Awards
Nomeado Best Cinematography


Chlotrudis Awards
Nomeado Best Cinematography

Costume Designers Guild Awards

• Excellence in Period/Fantasy Film

Hollywood Makeup Artist and Hair Stylist Guild Awards

• Best Character Makeup - Feature

International Film Music Critics Award (2011)

• Best Archival Release of an Existing Score - For Pee-wee's Big Adventure , Beetlejuice , Batman , Edward Scissorhands , The Nightmare Before Christmas , Big Fish , Charlie and the Chocolate Factory , Corpse Bride and Alice in Wonderland For the soundtrack album "The Danny Elfman & Tim Burton 25th Anniversary Music Box".

International Horror Guild
Nomeado Best Movie

Italian National Syndicate of Film Journalists
Indicado Best Foreign Director

Las Vegas Film Critics Society Awards

• Best Production Design

Nomeado Best Cinematography, Best Costume Design, Best Score

Los Angeles Film Critics Association Awards

• Best Production Design

MTV Movie Awards
Nomeado Best Villain - Christopher Walken

Motion Picture Sound Editors, USA
Nomeado Best Sound Editing - Effects & Foley

National Society of Film Critics Awards, USA
2nd place - Best Cinematography

New York Film Critics Circle Awards
2nd place - Best Cinematographer

Online Film Critics Society Awards

• Best Cinematography

Santa Fe Film Critics Circle Awards

• Best Cinematography

Satellite Awards

• Best Original Score
• Best Cinematography
• Best Sound
• Best Art Direction, Production Design
• Best Costume Design

Nomeado Best Performance by an Actor in a Motion Picture, Comedy or Musical - Johnny Depp, Best Visual Effects, Best Film Editing

Teen Choice Awards
Nomeada Film - Choice Actress - Christina Ricci

Young Artist Awards
Nomeada Best Performance in a Feature Film - Leading Young Actress - Christina Ricci